PDA

View Full Version : San Rafael Swell - Quandary Canyon 3B


rcwild
06-07-2008, 01:08 PM
A great introduction to technical canyons in the San Rafel Swell. The standard variation is a good choice for intermediate canyoneers. The Direct is a more challenging option requiring advanced skills in anchors and keeper pothole negotiation.

Rating: 3B II or III
Time Required: 5-10 hours
Longest Rappel:

Permit Information
No special permits required for canyoneering.

Camping/Lodging
There is excellent camping on the abandoned airstrip at Hidden Splendor.

Preferred Season
Spring (March - May) and Fall (September - November). Summer is ok but can be hot.

Water Concerns
wet/drysuit for spring or fall

Special Challenges
The Standard Quandary is fairly straight forward and suitable for those with intermediate skill level. The Direct presents considerably greater challenge and should only be attempted by people experienced in dealing with deep keeper potholes.

Equipment Suggestions
One 50m rope, webbing and rapid links, wet suit, pothole escape kit, standard canyon kit.

Topographic Maps
USGS 7.5' topo Hunt Draw Quadrangle, USGS 1:100,000-scale metric Hanksville/San Rafel Desert, Trails Illustrated San Rafel Swell.

Directions to Trailhead
From Green River go west on I-70 to Exit 147. Take Utah Hwy. 24 west toward Hanksville. This road parallels the San Rafel Reef on your right. After about 27 miles you will come to the Temple Mountain Road junction. Turn right on the Temple Mountain Road heading directly into the Reef. Pass the turn off to Goblin Valley on your left and continue past the end of the paved road and on through the Reef. The Temple Mountain Road runs northwest passing Flat Top (pt. 6480) on your left to a fork in the road at Taylor Flat. Take the left fork. After about four miles you will meet another road coming in from the right at Tan Seep. Stay left again. After about another mile you will come to yet another fork. Family Butte (pt. 7393) dominates the skyline in front of you. Stay left here and follow this road about ten miles across McKay Flat. At the next intersection one option takes you right to Tomsich Butte and Reds Canyon. However, you want to go left one more time and follow this winding road another fifteen miles or so down to the air strip at the old Hidden Splendor Mine.

Trailhead UTM Grid Coordinate

Approach
A little over two miles back up the Hidden Splendor Road from the air strip is a dirt track heading southeast just north of the nose of pt. 6245T. This dirt track stops roughly near an old wrecked car in the wash above Ramp Canyon. Follow the trail/mining road west from here winding along the eastern flank of pt. 6245T and through a small pass. This pass drops you into the head of Quandary Canyon. (The approach to Knotted Rope or Miner's Hollow is up a steep, loose gully to your right.) Head down canyon past a pretty natural bridge and into Quandary.

Canyon Entry UTM Grid Coordinate

Description: Standard Route
Narrows, down-climbs, rappels and potholes with some fourth class scrambling and down-climbing near the end.

After the third rappel but before the fourth the canyon opens a bit and you will see a gully climbing up to the left (the canyon fork is clearly visible on the Hunt Draw Quadrangle north of pt. 5363T). If you get to the fourth rappel you've gone too far. Take this gully up and descend ledges and slabs back into the main canyon.

Description: Quandary Direct
The Direct route will challenge your anchoring and keeper pothole escape skills. This choice should be avoided unless your skill level is up to the task. Take the right fork (just north of pt.5363T)and you will quickly come to the fourth rappel. The Direct continues from here.

Exit
When Quandary Canyon spits you out into the unnamed wash east of the reef strike left and follow this wash upstream a little less than two miles to the mouth of Ramp Canyon (at pt. 5650T). This "badlands" can be confusing and difficult to negotiate. Careful map reading however will allow you to avoid unnecessary explorations. Ascend Ramp Canyon (5.4-5.6 climbing at the "Ramp")to your car.

or ...

Head down the wash to Muddy Creek and walk back up through the Grand Gorge of Muddy Creek to Hidden Splendor.

Canyon Exit UTM Grid Coordinate

rcwild
06-09-2008, 01:43 PM
Reserved for accident reports from this canyon

rcwild
06-22-2008, 06:25 AM
Posted by shane on 28 Apr 2005:

A large number of folks skip what is noted as the third rappel in the description above and just downclimb the chute. Some don't even think of climbing up to the ledge (canyon right) and looking for anther option. This means they could still be looking for the "third" rap and get sucked into the keeper pothole section.... YMMV.

Posted by charlybldr on 25 Mar 2004:

A short version of the Quandary Direct can be accessed from the east or Factory Butte side.

Ten miles west of Hanksville the Factory Butte/Wild Horse road takes off to the right. Follow this road to its end at Muddy Creek and park. Don't bother trying to cross or drive up Muddy Creek. Plenty of experienced four-wheelers have gotten stopped cold here.

Hike up Muddy Creek about a mile and a half to the wash coming in on the right at pt. 4725T. About a mile up this wash Quandary Canyon comes in from the left northwest of pt. 4802T.

Ascend the Standard Quandary route to the top of the Direct. Turn and come back down the Direct.

Note: This version can be done in a relatively easy half day.

Posted by charlybldr 24 Oct 2006:
Cross Post from Yahoo Canyons
10/2006 Quandary Direct Anchors

Forgot to mention... the first anchor (previously a deadman) for the direct section in quandary is gone or at least buried in sand. We "last-man-down-jumps"ed it. The next party that goes here and wants to rappel ought to either dig up the existing deadman or create a new one. We downclimbed and jumped a lot of the drops in quandary that people often rappel, doing three rappels total that day and didn't really pay attention to the drops where people might typically rappel but we didn't. Seems one of the two drops in the upper canyon that we jumped might have been lacking an anchor too. We replaced damaged slings on the single-piton rappell across the sometimes-tyrolean keeper with a new piece of webbing. The rappel off the arch inside the pothole had about 8 slings around it still, which we didn't bother to do anything with. The final dual-piton rappel of the direct section looked pretty good.

PS
Down Quandary, Up Knotted Rope is a blast! (even at full water, most of the potholes and pools in KR require some degree of partner assisting or creative climbing to overcome and isn't for the solo canyoneer or beginner team.)