PDA

View Full Version : Two fatalities in South Fork Choprock Canyon, Escalante



mdd
04-20-2005, 12:12 PM
I'm sure more information will be posted here as more becomes known. We are keeping John and Brad's families and friends in our thoughts today.

Via http://www.sltrib.com/ci_2669790


Trip turns deadly for 2 BYU hikers
By Mark Havnes
and Michael N. Westley
The Salt Lake Tribune

ESCALANTE - The bodies of two Brigham Young University students were recovered from a pool of icy water Tuesday in a remote slot canyon about 35 miles southeast of Escalante.
Garfield County Sheriff Than Cooper, who participated in the search that began Saturday afternoon, said the bodies of John Anderson, 25, and Brad Underwood, 24, both of Provo, were found in the south fork of Choprock Canyon in the Glen Canyon National Recreation Area at about 2:30 p.m. in water 10 to 15 feet deep.
"They were found together in a pool," Cooper said. "We found their backpacks yesterday [Monday] and located them this afternoon."
Cooper did not know how the men died but suspected it was from hypothermia or drowning.
The bodies were flown by a Utah Department of Public Safety helicopter to Escalante, where they were identified
by relatives, then sent to the medical examiner's office in Salt Lake City for autopsies.
Cooper described the rugged area as grooved with canyons up to 300 feet deep and anywhere from 16 inches to 600 feet wide.
To navigate the canyon, the men were required to execute a series of rappels and swim through pools of water that are cold and exceptionally high this year. The men were equipped with wet suits and ropes.
Bureau of Land Management employees and the volunteer fire department from the town of Tropic helped in search efforts.
The area is adjacent to Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument, where the pair began their journey Wednesday at the Egypt trailhead, 26 miles south of State Route 12 off the Hole-in-the-Rock Road.
The search began after Underwood and Anderson failed to return at their designated time Saturday and family members contacted the sheriff's office.
As the search was under way Tuesday, family members from around Utah gathered at the trailhead.
Also on hand were Underwood's bishop and stake president with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Stake President Larry Johnson said Underwood was married in August and was expected to graduate from the LDS-run university on Friday with a degree in physics.
Underwood was also a cadet in the school's Air Force ROTC program and was expected to receive a commission on graduation, Johnson said.
"He was one of the most well-rounded people I know," said classmate David Cullen, who recalled Underwood's positive attitude and can-do spirit.
Underwood's brother-in-law, Michael Hoffman, traveled to Escalante from Layton to take part in the vigil.
He described Underwood as an experienced rock climber who had had his share of spills.
"But nothing like this," Hoffman said.
Several of Anderson's cousins were also on hand Tuesday.
Jason Despain, one of the cousins who had traveled to the trailhead from Riverton, described Anderson as thoughtful of others.
"He also had a great laugh and was afraid of firecrackers," Despain said. "He was in great shape and could climb where most people can't."
Anderson was a student in BYU's construction management program and was also scheduled to graduate Friday, said program chairman J.P. Christopherson.
"He was known by most of the students as 'Peaches,' " Christopherson recalled. He said Anderson was active in the development of the department's Web site and was well known by the 400 members of the department's student organization.
The loss of the men will be felt deeply by the BYU student population, said the school's media relations director, Carri Jenkins.
Before the bodies were discovered, a group of seven people from Bozeman, Mont., hiked out of the same area Tuesday afternoon, a couple of days later than planned.
Perry Fishbaugh, the leader of the group, which ranged in age from 17 to early 20s, did not expect the water to be as deep or as cold as it was.
They started their trek Saturday.
"By the end of the day [Sunday] we were shivering but had plenty of food and water," Fishbaugh said. "We found some shelter, started a fire and spent the night." Many of the canyons, he said, were clogged with logs and other floating debris.
mhavnes@sltrib.com
mwestley@sltrib.com

mdd
04-21-2005, 10:40 AM
Another article from the Salt Lake Tribune with more information. We'll post even further details as they become known.

Via http://sltrib.com/utah/ci_2677517


Slot canyons can be fatal traps for the adventurer
Wet, cold, fatigue: Canyoneering is a new sport, and a lot of the "expert" guidelines are inaccurate
By Mark Havnes
The Salt Lake Tribune


Garfield County Sheriff Than Cooper examines a pack brought out of Choprock Canyon on Tuesday where two BYU students died while canyoneering in the slot canyon. (Mark Havnes/The Salt Lake Tribune)
CEDAR CITY - Swimming through a pool 10 to 15 feet deep in Choprock Canyon, a group of seven hikers found what appeared to be an abandoned rope in the water. Thinking they could use the rope to get past a logjam in their path, they pulled it, only to see a gym shoe and a leg tangled up in it. They dropped the rope in panic.
Garfield County Sheriff Than Cooper and other rescuers heard the story from the group on Monday and had a feeling they had found the two missing hikers they had been looking for since Sunday.
"When they cooled down and went back and pulled up the rope, there was nothing on the end," Cooper said Wednesday. "But we had a pretty good idea of where to look."
On Tuesday, the searchers found the bodies of Brigham Young University
students John Anderson, 25, and Brad Underwood, 24, who went hiking in the Glen Canyon National Recreation Area on April 13, with plans to be out two days later. When they did not return by last Saturday afternoon - the pair did not register with the Bureau of Land Management field office in Escalante - family members notified the Sheriff's Office.
On Sunday, about 20 searchers hit the ground and began looking in Neon and Choprock canyons. A helicopter from the state Department of Public Safety was called in to help because of the remoteness of the area, said Cooper.
The helicopter spotted the seven hikers and communicated to them from the rim of Choprock Canyon on Sunday afternoon.
"The seven were struggling for their own safety," Cooper said, even though they had wet suits and other necessary equipment.
The group camped over Sunday night, and reached the mouth of Choprock Canyon on Monday, where they met with Cooper and told him what they had seen.
"We didn't dare tell the family until we were sure it was them," said Cooper.
On Tuesday morning four rangers with the National Park Service rappelled about 260 feet into the canyon and found the bodies of the two men about 2:30 p.m. in the pool of water. The men were wearing wet suits and had gear for rappelling.
Cooper said the temperature of the water was 36 degrees.
The bodies were hoisted to the canyon rim and then flown out by helicopter. After being identified by
relatives, the bodies were sent to the state Medical Examiner's Office in Salt Lake City to determine the cause of death.
The group of seven hikers ended their adventure on Tuesday, when they arrived at the Egypt Trailhead, 35 miles southeast of Escalante.
Perry Fishbaugh, the leader of the group from Bozeman, Mont., said conditions in the canyon forced the group to return to the trailhead two days later than expected.
Fishbaugh said Tuesday that places in the canyon get so narrow, he had to turn sideways to pass through.
Having hiked the area several times before, Fishbaugh said the water was higher and colder than he remembered from past trips.
That does not surprise Bill Heaton, a member of the American Canyoneering Association in Cedar City.
He said the growing sport of canyoneering, which involves rappelling down a canyon's drainage, has its dangers.
"It can be anything from just hiking to a few small rappels to some up to 300 feet," said Heaton on Wednesday.
He said Choprock Canyon is one where a person could easily die if they did not know what they were doing.
"What happens is even in a thick wet suit the water is so numbing cold your body temperature is going to drop and hypothermia starts setting in and that can be tragic," said Heaton, who has trained Iron County Search and Rescue members in rope techniques.
He said once committed to a canyon, there is usually no going back. "It's like rappelling into a toilet bowl," he said.
BLM Ranger Larry Vensel said that as the sport of canyoneering increases in popularity, so do the number of guide books and Web sites detailing routes in Utah's canyon country. Many, he warned, are inaccurate or lacking in detail.
His advice to people dropping into slot canyons: "Always get a permit."
mhavnes@sltrib.com

mdd
04-21-2005, 02:21 PM
The following was posted by Steve Cole over on the canyons egroup, and the information comes from Bill Wolverton. Reposted here with permission and many thanks.


Hi Guys,

This morning I spoke to Bill Wolverton, GCNRA backcountry ranger who
was involved in the recovery in Choprock. He was one of the first
persons on the scene after the Montana folks reported the bodies'
location. (BTW, the Montana folks *did* finish the canyon, albeit
later that planned, rather than retreat as I have seen posted
elsewhere.) Bill asked me to post his comments here so I'll relate
as much as I can recall.

Both guys were found together on the bottom of the same pool, not
floating. Both were wearing wetsuits and harnesses but neither was
tied into the rope. It has been mentioned that their rope was found
on top of a log jam. According to Bill the rope and log jam were
immediately *downstream* and right next to where the guys were
found. Bill speculated that they had tried to throw their rope on
top of the log jam hoping it would catch on something so they could
pull themselves out.

One intriguing piece of new info is that Mr. Wolverton was puzzled
as to why the guys were in the water in the first place in that
particular spot. He says that it would have been easy to stem or
chimney across without getting wet. Maybe they were already
fatigued and/or befuddled by hypothermia and used poor judgement.
Who knows? Also, the log jam was not particularly tall (only 5
feet, I think Bill said) so it should not have been difficult for a
couple of experienced climbers to get on top of it.

The bodies were hoisted out using z-rigs, etc. The rappel into the
canyon at the incident site was well over 200 feet. The canyon was
quite narrow at this point, so much so that it made the extraction
particularly difficult.

That's about as much as I can remember from my conversation with
Bill. Hope this adds a little to the accident analysis.

Regards,
Steve Cole

glennjd3
04-22-2005, 08:57 AM
That's about as much as I can remember from my conversation with
Bill. Hope this adds a little to the accident analysis.

Regards,
Steve Cole

Thanks for the information.

Jim

mrklusman
04-22-2005, 10:23 AM
From the NPS Morning Report:

Glen Canyon National Recreation Area (AZ,UT)
Two College Students Die in Backcountry Slot Canyon


On the morning of Sunday, April 17th, dispatch was advised of a search in progress in the Choprock and Neon Canyon areas of the Escalante drainage within Glen Canyon NRA. Two BYU students in their mid-twenties had entered the recreation area via the BLM Egypt trailhead on Wednesday evening to complete a circuit loop of the canyons. When the two failed to return on time, the family notified the Garfield County Sheriff’s Office. Searchers from the park and from the sheriff’s office were supported by rangers and a helicopter from Grand Canyon, local volunteer rescue groups from Tropic and Boulder, Utah, and Classic Aviation from Page, Arizona. A total of three helicopters and 32 searchers were involved. The bodies of the two students were found and eventually removed from Choprock canyon, one of the most technical, difficult slot canyons in southeast Utah – a canyon that is infrequently hiked due to the advanced skills required. The recovery efforts occurred in a long narrow slot section of the canyon that averaged 18 inches wide at the recovery site. The canyon at that location is over 200 feet deep, trends east and west, and receives no sunshine. Temperatures in the narrow, dark canyon were hovering around 40 degrees, with a water temperature in the low 40s. At the bottom of the slot, a log jam dam created a debris-filled pool 40 yards long, eight to 10 feet deep and less than two feet wide. The NPS recovery team of Brett Timm, Laurie Axelson, Derek Dahlremple, Bill Woverton, and Cathy Burns were starting the difficult process of removing the first victim when they found the second victim under the first and lying on the bottom of the pool. The cause of death is thought to be a combination of hypothermia and drowning. The medical examiners report is pending.
[Submitted by Mike Mayer, Chief Ranger]
----------------------

Hopefully there will be some lessons we can take away from this tragedy. Our thoughts and prayers are with John and Brad's family and friends.